Human Trafficking 2.0

The evolution of exploitation in the age of social media

Where the Sun Doesn’t Shine

A sign at the entrance reads: Welcome to Sunshine Liquor. But little sunlight makes its way into the messy fortress-like corner store at the intersection of Colorado Boulevard and Madre Street in Pasadena.

Sunshine Liquor and Market, where Christina Maricic, now 25, was kidnapped and trafficked as a young teenager.

These days, the large windows are covered with ads for cheap beer that block out the sun. Inside, there are tall metal bars on the inside of the glass. They offer a second layer of security. Even if someone broke through both, they would still have to climb over the mess of goods and piles of boxes stacked up near the windows. From the street, it is hard to see much of anything that happens inside Sunshine.

So it says a lot about the life of Christina Maricic, then a 14-year-old Mexican American girl who lived in a nearby group home for children in 2008, that she saw a place where people buy cigarettes and hard alcohol as her refuge.

One day, to escape the bullying children at the Rosemary Children’s Services home where fights were common and smoking weed was the norm, she took the three-minute walk to Sunshine. Dressed in her LA Dodgers skull cap and wearing acrylic french-tipped nails, the teenager was looking for a bag of Hot Cheetos and Arizona iced tea—her favorite combination.

Rosemary's Children Services in Pasadena, California.

Inside, a flamboyant and smooth-talking black man, who looked to be in his 30s, approached Christina. The man, who had an accent that sounded strange to her, wore white linen clothes and had keloid scars on his ears. He told her she was beautiful and he wanted her to meet his other girls, whatever that meant. He also told the 14-year-old he could help her make a lot of money.

Christina tried to ignore him, but the man became agitated and wouldn’t stop talking. Then, he and another large East African-looking man blocked the store’s two exits. Panicking, Christina tried to push past the man in linen, but he grabbed her and took her to a waiting white Range Rover with tinted windows. There, he repeatedly punched her in the face until she passed out.

Christina wasn’t just being kidnapped. She was one of the thousands of people who end up in the hands of traffickers in the United States each year. In all, the National Human Trafficking Hotline says that almost 11,000 cases of trafficking were reported directly to them in 2018.

According to the hotline, one case can refer to many people being trafficked, and more than 2,000 of the cases involved children and teenagers, especially from other parts of the world.

Here in Los Angeles, between 2010 and 2018, there were more than 170,000 reported cases of human trafficking.

Map of Los Angeles Sex Trafficking hubs of minors, compiled from LAPD data.

Sex trafficking is the most common, followed by labor trafficking. In 2018 alone, LAPD data indicates that there were 25,729 cases of human trafficking that involved “commercial sex acts.” A commercial sex act is defined as “any sex act on account of which anything of value is given to or received by any person,” according to U.S. Department of State.

The scale of the problem is no surprise to the staff of the Orange County District Attorney’s office. “I’d say in any given year, I encountered human trafficking survivors or survivors of those types of cases maybe twice a month,” said a lawyer in the office who spoke anonymously for the security of his clients.

Line Chart
Infogram

A Seven-Year Sentence

Every person who gets lured in by human traffickers has a unique story, but experts note that some people are more vulnerable than others.

Christina’s biological mother struggled with substance abuse, so she was placed in the foster system as a young girl. Christina seemed to get a new start when she was adopted by a family in the affluent neighborhood of La Cresta in Riverside County when she was 6 years old. But it was not the loving family she hoped for.

Instead of seeing Christina as their child, they quickly began to treat her like a servant, often making her wake up before daybreak to do chores, and they gave her a long list of additional tasks after school. Partly due to her heritage, they referred to her as their “Mexican worker."

They were just getting started. Christina explained she was beaten and tortured by the family. They broke some of her bones and didn’t get her proper medical care. Christina also recalled sexual abuse by her adoptive parents, who groomed her and forced her to perform sex acts on their older son.

In her accounts, there was no break from the horror. She was frequently left without food, water or anywhere to go to the bathroom. In an apparent effort to break her will, Christina’s adopted parents sometimes made her stand up at times when she needed to sleep.

Because of the neighborhood where she lived, Christina’s neighbors refused to believe that she was being mistreated. To them, she was a troubled former foster kid with an attitude problem. But after seven horrible years with the family, teachers at Christina’s school noticed bruises and reported the abuse.

‘If they catch me,’

‘imma get beat’

Authorities returned Christina back to the foster care system, where she was moved between several different facilities and group homes, eventually ending up at Rosemary.

Foster children are special targets of gangs because they have no family to look after them. People who have already been trafficked are especially vulnerable to re-trafficking within two years of being a victim because many suffer from debt bondage or psychological, emotional and economic conditions, according to the National Center for Biotechnology Information.

It was hardly a coincidence that traffickers would target Christina. So when the 14 year old regained consciousness in the back of the Range Rover after being taken from Sunshine liquor, she didn’t know where she was, how far she’d gone or where they were taking her.

Later, she gradually realized she had been moved to a home that was a base for a gang. “There was more girls in this house and it looked like a crack house. It was completely disgusting,” she later said. “There was like, I can see people were cooking, like, methamphetamines in the kitchen.”

The inhabitants were often aggressive, drunk, high and fighting. There, the men in charge started giving Christina alcohol, telling her it would calm her down. When she fought back, the gang members held her down and injected her arm with an unknown substance that knocked her out for hours or days.

Gang members took to raping Christina, she explained, individually and in groups. It all left her angry, scared and hopeless. Often, her captors hardly fed her. Between the hunger and the drugs, she spent weeks, maybe months “tired and in a daze.”

Then one night, Christina noticed people hurriedly running around the house, throwing things out of windows, screaming and shouting at one another, and trying to flush drugs down the toilet. That’s when she realized the police were on their way.

Sitting in the living room surrounded by panic and commotion, she realized this might be an opportunity. “I heard another voice inside me ... telling me: ‘You gotta go,’” Christina said, as tears welled up in her eyes. “And I just remember seeing the door and I remember being so scared because I was like, ‘If they catch me, imma get beat and imma be killed.”

Barefoot in short shorts and a tank top, she ran out an unlocked backdoor that had been left open, and kept running into the cold night for miles. Finally, she collapsed beside a library, in tears.

Church La Luz Del Mundo in East Los Angeles, Leader Naason Joaquin Garcia appeared June 5 in Los Angeles County Superior Court on charges of human trafficking, rape and child pornography.

Returning ‘Home’

By the library, Christina realized her captors hadn’t taken her far; she was maybe three or four freeway exits from Rosemary Children’s Services and Sunshine Liquor.

The thought of going back to Rosemary’s made her sad, but she didn’t know where else to go. She thought of suicide, but decided she’d been through enough already. Not knowing what to do, she went back to the group home.

“That’s why I went home, that’s why I didn’t keep running and that’s why I didn’t try to kill myself that day—because it was just too hard of a day,” she said, wiping tears from her face.

When Christina told the group home staff what she had been through, they called the police who transported her to a hospital for an obligatory rape-kit screening. Finally feeling safe at the hospital, Christina laid down on the bed and took her first deep breath.

Soon after, an officer handcuffed her to the bed. Police said she violated her probation by running away from the group home. She had left Rosemary to go to Sunshine Liquor because other girls at the group home had tried to stab her. “It’s like I escaped one thing but I’m going back to another … It was like non-stop,” she said as her eyes darted back and forth in disbelief. “I really wanted to die.”

The police, looking at her prior history with fighting and marijuana, didn’t believe her story of captivity and thought that she ran away to prostitute herself for drugs. They took Christina to juvenile hall. She stayed there for 60 days.

Christina was shell-shocked. “It took me a long time to just even get back to like normal talking and being okay. I felt really dirty for a long time.”

Once released, Christina said she was sent to another group home—and then passed between 13 more. She was also in and out of jail for a host of offenses, from fighting to the possession and dealing of marijuana.

Christina Maricic (center) featured on the USC paper for working with Lucero and Carmen Noyla (right, left) on initiatives to aid former foster youth in their transition to university

Opal Singleton, CEO of Million Kids, talks about one of her trainings and how children have been targeted for trafficking on social media.

Marek Vionnet, an Orange County district attorney, details how pimps target, coerce and abuse women.

Amber Davies, senior director of clinical programs for Saving Innocence, speaks about a story that has affected her work.

The Graduate

Although the pain remains with Christina, partly due to the physical and psychological damage, she has made great strides.

Over time, Christina learned ways to work through her trauma, partly by sharing her experience with other survivors, and partly by focusing on her studies.

It is important to surround survivors with a lot of love and give them the foundation they need to turn their nightmare into a success, said Opal Singleton, the president and CEO of Million Kids, a nonprofit dedicated to combating human and sex trafficking as well as child pornography and exploitation through education, prevention, training and support.

They are people who have been through more PTSD than your average service man. ... We need them to be leaders.”

“They not only are survivors, they’re thrivers. They are people who have been through more PTSD than your average service man. ... We need them to be leaders,” Singleton said.

The attorney in the Orange County DA’s office notes that women and children from unstable home environments are often targeted. What’s more, the most prevalent victims are from marginalized communities that are home to disproportionate numbers of people of color and LGTBQ+.

“The realities of human trafficking are often misjudged,” said Harmony Grillo, the founder of Treasures, a faith-based outreach and support group for women in the sex industry and victims of sex trafficking. “Our culture and media predominantly displays trafficking victims as caucasian females. However, most trafficking victims are women and girls of color,” she said.

Amber Davies of Saving Innocence, an organization that works to support children who have been recovered from traffickers, explains that though African-Americans make up 9 percent of the population in L.A. County, 60 to 70 percent of the kids being trafficked are from South LA, she said. “That’s where a lot of trafficking is happening.”

“Society at large forgets that these kids exist and that this is a big problem and that, you know, a lot of people don’t care about these kids,” Davies said.

After transferring from community college to USC, Christina, now 25, just completed her first year. She is working toward a master’s degree in public policy through the progressive degree program.

Interviewed a couple blocks from the center of the Historical South Central at her home near the university, Christina recounted her ordeal and explained how, after all of the pain and suffering, she created a small business, Christina’s Pathways to Success, LLC.

Through her business, she meets with law enforcement, social workers, resource parents and hospitals as a licensed continuing education instructor to help them understand how to identify and prevent human trafficking.

After all she has endured, her goals are clear. “I want to continue advocating for underrepresented communities,” she said. “I want to continue on educating public servant workers that work with at-risk youth, so that we can really prevent and help more youth out.”

IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA

ON HUMAN TRAFFICKING

In June, a man in Windsor Hills was arrestedafter he was caught luring more than a dozen women on social media to his house with the intent to traffic them. Earlier this year in February, a 35-year-old Los Angeles man was arrested after posing as a 13-year-old on TikTok in order to coerce children, as young as nine, to send him nudes and then blackmail them into sleeping with him.

Southern California is a major hub for human trafficking. 

While government organizations such as Homeland Security, the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) and the police department all work toward rescuing victims and prosecuting perpetrators, traffickers are increasingly using social media to contact vulnerable teenagers and sell them into sex work. 

The city of Los Angeles boasts a population of four million people. Additionally, an article by the Pew Research Center found that five out of every seven Americans are on social media, broadening the scope of possible victims for human traffickers. 

“Apps are not bad ... technology is not bad,” Opal Singleton, CEO and president of Million Kids, said. Millon Kids is a nonprofit that supports survivors and educates potential victims of new forms of trafficking. “But when we are putting our kids on the internet without explaining how it works, we're doing them a great disservice.” 

Apps like TikTok (formerly Musical.ly) provide a platform where anyone can create a short video, show it to the world, become viral or potentially get coerced into producing more videos by a stranger. 

“Let's take a video made by a 10-year-old that suddenly has 200,000 followers,” Singleton said. “If only 1 percent of them are bad guys, that is 2,000 pedophiles trying to talk to a 10-year-old.”

While social media gives traffickers wider access to victims, there are some resources available to survivors. Safe Horizon, the National Human Trafficking Hotline and Polaris Project are some organizations dedicated to helping and educating survivors. Whether it be helping trafficking victims find resources, peer counseling sessions or job interview training, some apps are working to combat the problem.

Here’s a list of anti-trafficking apps 

  1. Hotels-50k: This artificial intelligence tool utilizes a data set from roughly one million images from 50,000 hotels to train a computer vision system to identify objects, decorations, colors and other discernible markers present in the pictures. The tool works similarly to a facial recognition system for hotel rooms: researchers find images of victims in rented rooms, obscure the victim and tell the A.I. to look at everything else in the photos to determine where it was taken. 
  2. Lifeboat ACT Game: This app is a storyline-based game where you choose your character in a “life.” You learn the warning signs and the drastic changes that your friend is going through as a result of being trafficked. This educational game is run by the Lifeboat Project as a way to increase awareness of trafficking through gaming and education. 
  3. TraffickCam: This website and app enables you to combat sex trafficking by uploading photos of the hotel rooms that you’re staying in. Traffickers regularly post photos of their victims posed in hotel rooms for online advertisements. These photos then become evidence that can then be used to find and prosecute the perpetrators. The purpose of TraffickCam is to create a database of hotel room images that an investigator can search in order to confirm if other images were taken in the same location. According to Reuters, 150,000 people have installed the TraffickCam app.
  4. STOP APP: This is an app where users can send a text message or upload photos to a server if they detect suspicious trafficking or slavery-related activity. All of the information sent is anonymous and cannot be traced back to you, even if given to law enforcement. This app can be used anywhere in the world and is available in seven languages. The information that the user uploads is then analyzed and given to the appropriate law enforcement agencies.